What Do You Notice? What Do You Wonder?

Ask students to engage in a notice and wonder protocol remembering that everything and anything that comes to mind is fair game.

We suggest being intentional about using the language of “mugs” to represent each “portion” or “cup” of coffee because we will later be referencing how many metric “cups” of water are in the tank. This can help to avoid confusion.

Here’s some of the “everything and anything” students noticed and wondered on chart paper:

• I notice a coffee maker.
• I notice the tank looks full.
• I wonder if someone is going to make a mug of coffee?
• I wonder how many mugs of coffee one full tank can make?
• I noticed 3 buttons on the coffee machine.
• I wonder if the buttons represent different coffee sizes?
• I wonder if it is actually coffee or maybe they are making tea, hot chocolate, espresso, or some other hot drink?
• And many others…

Be sure to jot down this student thinking on the board, chartpaper, or even an online wall if teaching remotely.

At this point, take some time to try and address any of the noticing and wondering we can scratch off the list right away to acknowledge student voice and reassure students that we aren’t just fishing for the question we want to solve (although, in the end, we are very intentional about where we want to go with the task).

Prompt: Estimate

After answering any noticing and wondering we can eliminate right off the bat, we then land on this as our next wonder to explore:

How many mugs of coffee can you make with a full tank of water?

As usual, we will ask students to make an estimate.

If this is new for you, be sure to have a discussion about what an estimate is. In this case, we are trying to use whatever information we have access to in order to make a logical estimate or thoughtful estimate – not just a random guess.

In this case, we are only left to our intuition (what prior knowledge we have about coffee makers – probably little for elementary and middle schoolers) and spatial reasoning (what we can see and compare to other objects in the video).

Encouraging students to set themselves a range is also a great strategy. Ask students:

What’s a number you know is too low? Like it MUST be more than that…

then

What’s a number you know is too high? Like it MUST be less than that…

If you’re finding that students are giving ranges from 0 to 100 or maybe even 0 to 1000, then ask students:

Can you be RISKIER than that? I think you can…

Not only is estimation extremely important for students to develop number sense, but it is also a great way to help build a positive, growth mindset learning culture. Right now, everyone is likely “off” and that’s O.K.! The important part is asking students to try to convince their neighbours of why they think their estimate is a reasonable one.

Be sure to have students share out their estimates and jot them down on your whiteboard, chalkboard, or chart paper. Lately, I’ve been jotting student estimates on a number line which is a great visual to “see” what MOST kids believe and to create a “class range”.

Information: Update Estimates

Now, show students the following video and allow them to update their estimates.

While students discuss with their elbow partners how they might want to “up” or “bring down” their estimates based on the information that there are 8 metric cups of water in the tank, some students might have more noticing and wondering to share.

Some wonders that often come up at this point for students who have this machine or a similar one at home is:

• Will we be using the small, medium, or large buttons on the machine?
• Do we care how full each mug is?
• Will all of the water go through the machine?
• And many others…

These are all great questions that show students are “IN” this context and they are now eager to dive in.

I will quickly try to answer these questions including that we are going to push the large button for each mug.

As for how “full” each mug is, I often tell a story about having family over and I don’t care how full the mug is, once the machine is finished pouring, that’s what you get!

And finally, for the question regarding whether all of the water will be used; I typically say:

I’m not sure? But… let’s assume it will since our wonder is to know how many mugs a full tank will make.

After one more round of students “updating estimates” and having students hold each other accountable, we then show the reveal video.

Reveal

**Note that although in the video it appears that there are 6 mugs, only 5 were filled. The “add water” light illuminated before starting to fill the 6th cup.